Protects land for community use; protects animal habitat
Avoids environmental harms of embalming, use of concrete or metal grave liners, and imported or manufactured casket materials
Flame Cremation
Emits 250 to 536 lbs. of carbon per person
Burns fossil fuels (natural gas) 2 - 3 hours at 1700 - 1900° F
Releases mercury, nitrous oxide, and particulate matter into air and water (Minnesota study 14% of mercury emission attributable to crematories)
Nutrients incinerated or locked and unavailable
Phosphorus run-off from scattering creates algae bloom that kills fish and plants; girdles trees, killing microbial and plant communities
Increased risk of radiopharmaceutical contamination for crematory operators (Journal of the American Medical Association, 2.26.19)
Final product: 7 - 10+ lbs. of pulverized bone comprised of calcium phosphate and sodium (pH of 11.8; 200 – 2000x too alkaline for plants/roots to tolerate)
Alkaline Hydrolysis (water cremation, bio cremation, aquamation, aqua cremation)
Emits 250 lbs. of carbon per person through applying 100 - 300 gallons of 200 - 350◦ water pressure in a potassium hydroxide alkaline solution (lye) for 3 - 12 hours
Cytotoxins and embalming fluid neutralized; mercury captured but not mitigated
Uses 80% less energy than flame cremation; emits 20% less CO2
Leftover: 100 – 300 gallons of effluent, no current regulations for safe disposal
Final product: 10 – 15 lbs. finely pulverized bone (20 -32% more than flame cremation, needing larger urns)
Carbon emissions inestimable at this time that include:
Industrial facility construction if in an urban or suburban setting
Commercial production and transport of feedstock and bulking agents such as alfalfa and wood chips used for the comporting process (for reference, alfalfa production uses a third of the water needed for livestock irrigation which accounts for 86% of the water draining the Colorado River Basin)
Fuel to transport and dispose of a pick-up truck’s load quantity of leftover composted material for each composted body to a separate location
Resulting composted material can be retained by the family or donated.
Material may be disposed of on established, non-profit conservation property to support soil restoration in depleted areas (beware of surface dumping that is not part of a conservation plan).
Takes 2+/- months for microbes to break down tissue
Low impact if managed as natural decomposition in a non-industrial setting
Fuel costs to control temperature, humidity, and other facility functions in industrial facilities
Bones removed, pulverized, returned to mix
Final product: 1 - 1.5+ cubic yards leftover composted material to transport (approx. 1,685.55 lbs./+ disposed of pp, or one truckload)
For State-based, non-commercial information on care for the dead, go to Oregon Funeral Resources at Oregonfuneral.organd Washington Funeral Resources at Washingtonfuneral.org For research-based information on environmentally responsible disposition options, see: Cremation Curious https://vimeo.com/767868604 The Natural Burial Experience https://vimeo.com/769978957 For educational programs and courses focusing on end-of-life issues, go to: RedesigningtheEnd.com https://www.redesigningtheend.com